The real winner is...?

Ok the long-debated question, which is better:

player 1- Attack lvl: 99 Strength lvl: 1 Defence lvl: 1

Player 2- Attack lvl: 1 Strength lvl: 99 Defence lvl: 1

Player 3- Attack lvl: 1 Strength lvl: 1 Defence lvl: 99


they all have benefits and disadvantages~

Attacker: can use any weapon except for ones including def or str level requirements, so hit somewhat higher than 1 damage sometimes.
Can get hit easily because of low defence.

Strengther: Can hit extremely high!
can only use low leveled weapons because of attack requirements, and hits rarely.

Defender: Rarely gets hit
Cant hit too often, and doesnt hit high.

none of the fighters will wear armour to make it fair

Please leave the reason you think it would win so we can start up a nice long debate and make this interesting.

I chose Attacker, because although he may get hit hard by strengther, the strengther wont hit him enough times to kill him, and the defender may take a little while to kill, but since he has 1 attack he wont hit me very often, so the attacker would hit a good few multiple 1's on him until he died.

no, no pots or any skill boosting things.